most comfortable steel toe boots

10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women

Are you in a hurry? Then we recommend the Timberland PRO Men’s Boondock 6″ Waterproof Non-Insulated Work Boot for men and Timberland Pro Women’s Titan Waterproof Boot for women as the most comfortable steel toe boots you can buy right now. Otherwise, read our full review to find out other options that may be right for you.

If you work on a building site, warehouse, or any place that presents unpredictable hazards, it’s more than likely that you require steel-toed boots to protect your feet from falling or rolling objects. It’s a health and safety requirement in a lot of these places but with footwear designed with protection as a priority, it can be tough to find the most comfortable steel toe boots.

That is why we have put together this buyer’s guide. In it, we will review some of the best products on the market and help you decide which ones are best for your needs.

Boots we reviewed in this guide:

Best Steel Toe Work Boots For Men

Best For Smaller Feet: Timberland Pro Men’s Pitboss 6” Steel-Toe Boot
“Great boots, better fit for smaller sizes.”

Best For Onlookers: Caterpillar Men’s 2nd Shift 6” Steel Toe Boot
“You can get all the safety features and look cool too.”

Best For Comfort: KEEN Utility Men’s Braddock Mid Steel Toe Work Boot
“Top of the line comfort for less $$ than our top pick”

Best Lightweight Boots: Skechers USA Men’s Pilot Utility Boot
“You won’t even notice you’re wearing these”

Best Overall: Timberland PRO Men’s Boondock 6″ Waterproof Non-Insulated Work Boot
“All round champion with great looks, comfort, and durability.”

 

Best Steel Toe Shoes For Women

Best Overall: Timberland Pro Women’s Titan Waterproof Boot
“Top Quality all-rounder”

Best on a budget: Caterpillar Women’s Mae Steel Toe Waterproof Construction Boot
“If you can’t afford our top pick”

Most Versatile Option: KEEN Utility Women’s Atlanta Cool ESD Steel Toe Work Shoe
“Great boots for work, hiking, and running!”

Most Durable Option: KEEN Utility Women’s Detroit Mid Steel Toe Work Boot
“Should last a while”

Best for Onlookers: Skechers Women’s Synergy Sandlot Steel Toe Work Shoe
“Look great, feel great.”

Things To Consider Before Buying Steel Toe Boots

If you’re looking for steel toe boots then it’s most likely you need a product that first and foremost protects your feet. While comfort is also important, you should work out the exact protective requirements you have before buying some. This is because each shoe will protect you against different things. Extra features such as electrical hazard protection, waterproofing, and much tougher steel toes are welcome.

Best Steel Toe Boots For Men

Best Overall: Timberland PRO Men’s Boondock 6″ Waterproof Non-Insulated Work Boot

 

10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women
Buy On Amazon

You won’t find a better looking steel toe boot that packs all the features as our top pick. Period. The Timberland Pro Men’s Boondock boot sports a patented Anti-Fatigue waterproof protection and rugged weather-ready outsoles that make them almost invincible in harsh weather conditions. They are comfortable, shock-proof, and have a very high rating for slip-, oil-, and water-resistance. If you’ll buy only one pair of work boots this year, this is the boot to buy.

Key Features

  • Waterproof leather, waterproof membranes; options are available with 200g/400g/600g and 1000g of insulation
  • All-weather outsoles perform in cold weather; some styles are insulated
  • Available in safety and soft toe options
  • Slip-resistance
  • Shock-proof

Best For Smaller Feet: Timberland Pro Men’s Pitboss 6” Steel-Toe Boot

 

10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women
Buy On Amazon

With the Pitboss line of boots, Timberland has designed a product that is tough enough to protect your feet in the most hazardous environments while providing the comfort and support you need to keep working for longer periods of time without your feet suffering.

In terms of safety, these boots offer a tough steel toe that adheres to ANSI safety standards, they keep you safe from open circuits with their electronic hazard protection, and the outsole is slip-resistant for both liquids and oils, so you’ll retain the traction wherever you go.

You will find them extremely comfortable too. The toe box is wider than normal to give your feet more space and feel far less constricted. The removable sock liner protects your feet from rubbing, and the polyurethane footbed and midsole provide cushioning and support as well as antimicrobial protection to prevent odors.

Key Features

  • Made from leather
  • ​Padded collar and tongue
  • ​Polyurethane midsole that absorbs shocks
  • ​Anti-slip
  • Spacious toe box

Best for Onlookers: Caterpillar Men’s 2nd Shift 6” Steel Toe Boot

 

10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women
Buy On Amazon

As you’d expect from Caterpillar, these boots have been designed to be tough, sturdy and are built to last. It features a rounded steel toe that conforms to the usual safety standards and will protect your feet from heavy objects falling or rolling onto them. They offer electrical hazard protection and are made from an extremely durable material that will endure the most intense of environments. The outsole is made from tough rubber and is anti-slip even on oily surfaces.

​The padded ankle and tongue will stop your feet from rubbing against the tougher materials and, along with the strong midsole provide support. They also come with a Climasphere sock liner which keeps your feet dry, feeling fresh and odor-free throughout the day.

Key Features

  • Made from leather
  • ​Padded ankle
  • ​Oil resistant outsole
  • ​Climasphere sock liner
  • Rounded steel toe

Best for Comfort: KEEN Utility Men’s Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work Shoe

 

10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women
Buy On Amazon

While these boots from KEEN certainly have you covered in terms of strength and safety, they incorporate a number of features to ensure your feet feel great while wearing them.

The steel toe conforms to the required safety standards, the rubber outsole is slip and oil resistant, and the entire product is made from a durable leather and mesh mix to ensure they hold up during intensive situations.

They feature a dual-density EVA midsole designed to add comfort, absorb shocks and provide firm structural support; a removable dual-density footbed that provides a good amount of cushioning, and a breathable mesh liner to keep your feet cool in warm environments.

Key features

  • Made from leather and mesh
  • ​Slip and oil resistant
  • ​Dual-density molded EVA midsole
  • ​Breathable mesh liner
  • Removable dual-density footbed

Best Lightweight: Skechers USA Men’s Pilot Utility Boot

 

10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women
Buy On Amazon

Skechers are well worth considering if you’re looking for a much lighter pair of boots that are just as durable and reliable.

The lightly padded footbed feels great and, along with the molded midsole, absorbs the shocks that would otherwise transfer through to your feet and ankles. The padded collar and tongue provide ankle support and prevent any rubbing so you won’t get any blisters in those areas.

The sole is man-made from a thick, durable rubber so you will be confident in the traction provided across all surfaces. They are waterproof so your feet will never get wet, and the six-eye lacing system ensures a tight, comfortable fit.

Key Features

  • Made from leather
  • ​Padded collar and tongue
  • ​Lightly padded footbed
  • ​Lugged rubber outsole
  • Lightweight design

Best Steel Toe Boots For Women

Best Overall: Timberland Pro Women’s Titan Waterproof Boot

 

10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women
Buy On Amazon

These Timberlands are packed full of handy features that provide the toughness and safety you need on a worksite while being really comfortable to wear for long periods of time.

It features an alloy safety toe, slip-resistant outsole, wide toe box, comfort mesh lining with anti-microbial properties to reduce odors, and overall rugged construction. The added polyurethane midsole and footbed provide your feet and ankles with support and cushioning as well as really good shock absorption. You even get some padding to the tongue and collar that adds to the comfort and prevent blisters from forming.

Key Features

  • ​Made from leather
  • ​TiTAN alloy safety toe
  • ​Mesh comfort lining
  • ​Slip-resistant outsole
  • Polyurethane midsole

Cons

  • Hard toe box area
  • Half size smaller than a regular fit

Best on a budget: Caterpillar Women’s Mae Steel Toe Waterproof Construction Boot

 

10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women
Buy On Amazon

This nice pair of boots from Caterpillar are not too heavy and have a spacious toe box that doesn’t smash your toes. The insert that comes in this boot is removable, so you can easily replace them with orthotic inserts for special foot conditions like high arches and flat feet.

They’re water-resistant and can be used in the rain or muddy areas without any hassles. The upper part is made up of leather, with a rubber sole and other materials for an overall classic look. They are sturdy, comfortable, good-looking and very well-priced.

Key features

  • Electrical Hazard Protection
  • Slip Resistant
  • Cement Construction and PU Midsole
  • Steel shank and nylon mesh footbed

Cons

  • These boots need to be broken in
  • Sizes run from half to one size bigger than a regular fit.

Most Versatile Option: KEEN Utility Women’s Atlanta Cool ESD Steel Toe Work Shoe

 

10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women
Buy On Amazon

These shoes from KEEN are really tough and sure to keep your feet safe in dangerous environments. The steel toes are designed in line with industry standards, and yet KEEN managed to make them appear inconspicuous. They manage to tick a lot of boxes for most buyers. They are very comfortable, lightweight, and sport an easy no-tie lace that gives it a sporty appearance. With the right pair of insoles, these can easily be used for hiking or running!

Key Features

  • Made from water-resistant leather and textile
  • ​Breathable mesh liner
  • ​Dual-density EVA footbed
  • ​Slip-resistant outsole
  • Electrical hazard resistant

Cons

  • Original Insoles are disappointing
  • Not great for cold weather use

Most Durable Option: KEEN Utility Women’s Detroit Mid Steel Toe Work Boot

 

10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women
Buy On Amazon

These shoes, also from KEEN, come with a slightly different set of features to the previous pair that make them more suitable as the most comfortable steel toe work boots for multi-purpose environments. They feature plenty of padding for comfort, while still ensuring your feet remain safe.

It sports a removable EVA footbed that is quite bouncy and responsive, Nubuck leather upper that is completely waterproof so your feet will stay dry, and some breathable fabric to ensure they are well ventilated. Soles are slip-resistant to water and oil.

Key Features

  • Made from leather and textile
  • ​Dual-density midsole
  • ​Removable EVA footbed
  • ​Torsion stability ESS shank
  • Aggressive tread for stability

Cons

  • These shoes are ugly (In my own opinion!)
  • A bit pricier than the alternatives

Best for Onlookers: Skechers Women’s Synergy Sandlot Steel Toe Work Shoe

 

10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots in 2020 for Men and Women
Buy On Amazon

Overall these are a stylish, comfortable shoe to wear if you are working in an environment that requires you to have steel toe shoes. These delightful pair from Skechers do not need to be worn in at all, they’re just great out of the box. These are highly recommending for any lady who has a wider foot, needs the toe space and would like the comfort that these shoes provide. And did we mention that they come at a great price too?

Key Features

  • Made from leather and synthetic materials
  • ​Padded collar and tongue
  • ​Protects against electrical hazards
  • ​Slip-resistant
  • Cushioned insole

Cons

  • It comes in larger than a regular fit.
  • Very little cushion from insoles/inserts

Bottomline

The priority when working in dangerous places is protection, but there’s no reason you can’t be comfortable at the same time. Wearing bad boots can increase the pressures going through your feet and result in pain far earlier than necessary. By finding the right boots you will be able to work longer and minimize these negative effects.

While you can’t really go wrong with any of our selections, we recommend the Timberland PRO Men’s Boondock 6″ Waterproof Non-Insulated Work Boot for men, and Timberland Pro Women’s Titan Waterproof Boot for women. Both provide similar feel and comfort and are very durable, so you won’t be in the market for a new pair of boots anytime soon!